Tootsie Roll: The Penny Candy That Became America's Biggest Candy Empire

Leo Hirschfeld was an Austrian Jewish immigrant, the son of a candy maker, and the inventor of a chocolate-flavoured sweet that would not melt in an American summer. It could be made cheaply, wrapped individually, and sold for a penny. He named it after his daughter Clara, whose nickname was Tootsie.

That penny sweet became the first individually wrapped penny candy in America, the sweet soldiers carried into two wars, and the foundation of one of the largest confectionery groups in the United States. For more American heritage brands, see American sweets older than your grandparents.

The Founding Story, and the Problem With It

Tootsie Roll Industries dates the sweet to 23 February 1896, sold from Hirschfeld's small Brooklyn shop. It is on the company's own website and it is repeated everywhere. It may not be true.

Samira Kawash, Professor Emerita at Rutgers University, went through the documentary record and found a different timeline. Hirschfeld appears to have been working for the candy firm Stern and Saalberg from the early 1890s rather than running an independent shop. He applied for a patent on the sweet's distinctive texture in 1907 and was granted it in 1908. Stern and Saalberg began marketing and advertising it in 1909. Kawash's conclusion is blunt: the patents, trademarks and advertising all put the Tootsie Roll in motion between 1907 and 1909, and the 1896 Brooklyn store invention is a myth.

The name has a complication too. Hirschfeld had already invented Bromangelon, the first commercially successful powdered gelatin dessert, which beat Jell-O to market by two years. Its child spokesperson was called Tootsie. So the sweet may well have been christened in Clara's honour, as the company says, but she had been lending her nickname to a product for some years before the sweet existed. Even the spelling is contested, appearing as both Hirschfeld and Hirshfield depending on the source.

None of this makes the sweet less remarkable. It makes the company's history a good deal more interesting than the version on the wrapper.

The First Individually Wrapped Penny Candy

The innovation that mattered was not the flavour but the wrapper. American penny candy was sold loose from jars, scooped out and handed over in paper. Wrapping each piece kept it clean, stopped pieces sticking together, and gave every sweet its own identity on a counter full of anonymous ones.

The recipe mattered as much. Cocoa, sugar and condensed milk in a specific combination produced what the patent described as a peculiar mellow consistency — firm enough to hold shape in warm weather, soft enough to chew. It is not chocolate in the strict sense, and that is precisely the point: it delivers chocolate flavour in a format that survives an August afternoon, at a time when American summers meant melted confectionery and no air conditioning to prevent it.

Two Wars and a Penny Sweet

Tootsie Rolls went to war twice. In the Second World War the US military put them in field rations: non-perishable, heat-stable, fast sugar energy, and small enough to carry without adding weight to an already heavy pack.

Korea produced the story that has outlived everything else. At the Battle of Chosin Reservoir in November 1950, a regiment of US Marines was encircled by Chinese forces in temperatures approaching minus thirty-six. A radio operator called for resupply of 60mm mortar shells using their code word: Tootsie Rolls. The operator receiving the message did not know the code, read it literally, and arranged an airdrop of actual sweets.

The Marines ate them, and then found a second use. Softened in the mouth and pressed into a bullet hole or a split fuel line, Tootsie Roll froze solid at those temperatures and held as a temporary seal. Marines patched jeep radiators and fuel lines with confectionery. Survivors of Chosin have been talking about it in interviews ever since.

The Tootsie Pop and the Question Nobody Has Answered

In 1931 an employee named Luke Weisgram was chewing a Tootsie Roll while eating a lollipop, and the combination suggested a product. The Tootsie Pop — hard candy shell, Tootsie Roll centre — launched the same year and worked immediately.

In 1969 the Doner advertising agency made what became one of the most-watched commercials in American television history. A boy asks a series of animals how many licks it takes to reach the centre. Mr Owl takes the pop, counts two licks, then bites through it and answers three. The world may never know. It ran in various edits for over fifty years, and Mr Owl was voiced by Paul Winchell, who was also the voice of Tigger for Disney.

The question has attracted genuine academic attention. A Purdue University licking machine averaged 364; their human volunteers managed 252. A University of Michigan machine reached 411. A group of school students averaged 144. The answer, honestly, is somewhere between 144 and 411 depending on who or what is doing the licking.

The Empire: Acquisitions That Built a Portfolio

From the 1970s the story becomes one of acquisition. Dots arrived in 1972 — the fruit gumdrop that has sat in American cinema concessions since 1945. Blow Pops and Charms followed in 1988 in a sixty-five million dollar deal that brought in the bubble-gum-filled lollipop and Charms Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy, and made Tootsie Roll Industries the largest lollipop producer in the world overnight.

Junior Mints came in 1993. Created in 1949 and named after the Broadway show Junior Miss, they became the defining cinema sweet for a generation of American filmgoers. Dubble Bubble followed in 2004 — the original American branded bubble gum, invented in 1928 by Walter Diemer, an accountant who stumbled on a formula that could hold a bubble while experimenting in his spare time. For the full story see the bubblegum complete guide.

The Range at Sweet and Glory

The Tootsie Industries range spans all six brands. Tootsie Rolls from retail formats through to large cases for scoop bins. Tootsie Frooties across a wide fruit range. Tootsie Pops in original and Wildberry box formats. Junior Mints, Dots, Blow Pops, Charms Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy and Dubble Bubble each have dedicated ranges.

The seasonal offer is unusually strong: Ghost Dots and Witches Brew Cotton Candy for Halloween, Tootsie Roll Elf Bites and Dots Lumps of Coal for Christmas, and USA Flag Midgees for the Fourth of July. Browse the Tootsie brand page for current availability.

Why the Portfolio Matters for Retailers

One company covers almost every occasion. The Tootsie Industries portfolio spans American theatre candy through Junior Mints, Dots and Tootsie Pops; the lollipop category through Blow Pops and Charms; gum through Dubble Bubble; cotton candy through Fluffy Stuff; chewy sweets through Tootsie Rolls and Frooties; and both Halloween and Christmas seasonal lines.

For a retailer building an American section that is unusual depth from a single brand family — one supplier relationship covering categories that would otherwise need five. See the American candy section setup guide for how to lay it out.

No minimum order. Free first parcel on orders over £150 ex VAT (additional boxes £7.10 each). Free pallet delivery over £650 ex VAT. Dispatched from Manchester. Create a free account to browse and order.
 

Frequently Asked Questions

How many licks does it take to get to the centre of a Tootsie Pop? Nobody agrees, which is the entire joke. Real studies have tried: a Purdue University licking machine averaged 364 while their human volunteers managed 252, a University of Michigan machine reached 411, and a group of school students averaged 144. So the honest answer is somewhere between roughly 144 and 411 depending on who, or what, is doing the licking.

Was the Tootsie Roll really invented in 1896? The company says so, but the documentary evidence points elsewhere. Rutgers professor Samira Kawash found that Leo Hirschfeld was working for the firm Stern and Saalberg rather than running his own Brooklyn shop, patented the sweet's texture in 1907, was granted it in 1908, and saw it marketed from 1909. Her conclusion is that the 1896 corner-shop invention is a myth. The sweet is real; the origin story appears to have been tidied up later.

Are Tootsie Rolls chocolate? Not strictly. The recipe uses cocoa, sugar and condensed milk in a combination that delivers chocolate flavour without being chocolate in the technical sense. That was deliberate — it was designed to hold its shape in summer heat at a time when American shops had no air conditioning and real chocolate turned to liquid. The same heat stability is why it ended up in military rations.

Why did soldiers use Tootsie Rolls in the Korean War? Because of a radio mix-up at the Battle of Chosin Reservoir in 1950. Marines requested mortar shells using their code word, Tootsie Rolls, and an operator who did not know the code airdropped actual sweets. In temperatures near minus thirty-six the Marines discovered that softened Tootsie Roll froze solid, so they used it to plug bullet holes in fuel lines and radiators. It is probably the strangest field expedient in confectionery history.

What brands does Tootsie Roll Industries own? Far more than the Tootsie Roll. The company owns Tootsie Pops, Frooties, Junior Mints, Dots, Blow Pops, Charms, Charms Fluffy Stuff cotton candy and Dubble Bubble, built up through decades of acquisitions. The 1988 Charms deal alone made it the largest lollipop producer in the world.

Related guides: Hot Tamales complete UK guide · Mike and Ike complete UK guide · Bubblegum: the complete guide · American sweets older than your grandparents · Sweets and snacks from movies and TV · American candy section setup guide · Most popular American sweets UK